Everyone is shocked when Zach announces that the next step in their evening is an old-fashioned murder game. Ryan, Greenlee and Kendall all agree to the game, until Bianca shows up. Initially they want to stop the game, but Bianca wants it to proceed. As the game play cards are handed out, the players soon realise that there's more than just a game going on because all of the cards are eerily similar to their real-life personalities.